Mistaken Identity

A couple of months ago I wanted to buy a new sofa. I found something that looked great in my local online sales paper, so I had to decide whether to go and see it. This involves hiring a car or taking a train and bus, because it was not close to my house and I don’t have a car of my own here in the US. Another possibility was just to hire a van, go and see it and buy it on the spot, a slightly riskier option.

So I did what many do, I looked up the seller via Google to see who he was. He turned out to be the CEO of a local business, so I made my decision. I hired a van and drove out, bought it on the spot, a lovely piece. I based the decision on the seller’s Linkedin profile, presuming that I had the right person from the name, and all went well.

The BBC recently broadcast a program on the World Service Outlook program along the same lines, but with a different outcome. It is available on Podcast here, but I would like to outline the story for you all.

In 2009 Iran saw street protests following the disputed presidential elections. Violence flared and a young woman was shot dead. Her name was Neda Agha-Soltan. Journalists from the international press soon picked up on the story, and rather like me searched Facebook and other sites for a photo of the victim. They found one and published it.

The next day Neda Soltan, a university professor saw her photos in the press. They had the wrong person. Obviously this may have caused some distress for her friends and family, so she contacted the press institutions and told them of their mistakes. They however continued to use her photo, and soon it was appearing on leaflets and became the face that distinguished the protests.

Johnny Hankins, is it me?

Johnny Hankins, American Footballer.

A few days later government secret service officers turned up at the professor’s house. They wanted to prove that the rumours of the death were all false, a CIA or EU plot to discredit the government, and they had proof that Neda was still alive. They wanted her to come forward and display to the world that she was still with us.

When she refused she was arrested. Upon her temporary release her friends managed to smuggle her out of the country, into Turkey and on to Germany where she claimed political asylum. She is currently in the US but has not seen her family and cannot return to Iran.

Jonny hankins again

The Internet has given journalists incredible tools and access to information, but here a mistake has ruined somebody’s life. The first thing people do when they want to learn about a person is type their name into their favourite search engine. Facebook is like a CV, but contains far more intimate and possibly compromising information, but users seem not to take this into consideration.

Another Johnny hankins

Another Johnny hankins

In the case above there seems to be no recourse to the law, and anyway it would not help. A bit of responsibility wouldn’t go amiss  on both sides though!

11 thoughts on “Mistaken Identity

  1. Christopher (admin team)

    I think I understand you. There was Person 1 who very unfortunately died, and in searching for a photo, the press found a picture of Person 2 who had the same name as Person 1. They wrongly used the photo, and despite Person 2 telling them this, there was then an effort to prove that Person 1 was still alive, as people thought the living Person 2 was Person 1.

    If my probably more confusing understanding is correct, I think that is terrible! I suppose you really don’t appreciate the value of your identity until it is gone.

    Careless journalism cost a woman her life, she now has to live in fear of arrest and has had to leave her normal life. Terrible.

    A really interesting story, and a great example of how the internet can be very dangerous! That said, it is such a fantastic thing too.

    • This reminds me of when they played the wrong national anthem last year at the shooting competition. They played the Borat version of the Kazak anthem from the film, very insulting! The organizers had downloaded it.

  2. Journalism is a sensitive activity. It can have a huge impact, both negative or positive, on a person if their identity is mistaken for somebody else’s. A few weeks ago, my friend’s photo was in a local newspaper but the name was misspelled. Though it wasn’t creating much of a problem for him, he contacted the newspaper and made them issue an apology. We made the best of it an had a bit of fun with him during this time though.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *